Moonwalking with Einstein by Joshua Foer
Moonwalking with Einstein is a book by Joshua Foer that looks at the modern revival of the 2,500 year old craft of memory. (Edit: the techniques are even older than that. See Lynne Kelly’s Memory Craft) The book describes the journey of the author as he goes from a journalist who is writing an article about memory competitions, to a mental athlete, obsessed with the sport, who eventually wins the 2006 USA Memory Championship.
. I’m writing this book review from the perspective of someone who is training in competitive memory techniques with the intention of entering the competitions that Joshua Foer writes about in this book.
The early part of the book covers stories that most mnemonists (and mnemonists-in-training) will be familiar with like Simonides, Shereshevsky, and how the brain structure of London taxi drivers is physically different from most other people.
The book explores many fascinating aspects of human memory as Foer meets with well-known savants and brain researchers as he trains for the 2006 USA Memory Championship.
Foer’s memory training is assisted by Grand Master of Memory, Ed Cooke, who appears throughout the book with humorous quotes:
“I have to warn you,” Ed said, as he delicately seated himself crosslegged, “you are shortly going to go from having an awed respect for people with a good memory to saying,’ Oh, it’s all a stupid trick.‘” He paused and cocked his head, as if to see if that would in fact be my response. “And you will be wrong. It’s an unfortunate phase you’re just going to have to pass through.”
The first thing that really stood out for me in Moonwalking with Einstein is how it captures many accurate things about the field of memory sports. Near the beginning of the book, Foer writes:
Ed had explained to me that the competitors saw themselves as “participants in an amateur research program” whose aim was to rescue a long-lost tradition of memory training that had disappeared centuries ago.
I imagine that most highly dedicated memory enthusiasts have these kind of thoughts, but there are very few people to share them with who understand. To see them in a mainstream book is a great thing.
Since most readers of this website are probably searching for information on memory techniques, I’ve listed a few samples of the memory tips from the book below. The book isn’t a “how-to” manual, but there were many interesting techniques mentioned in passing:
Using body parts as memory palace locations on a large scale:
Dr. Yip Swee Chooi, the effervescent Malaysian memory champ, used his own body parts as loci to help him memorize the entire 56,000-word, 1,774-page Oxford Chinese-English dictionary.
Edit: as Yan mentioned in the comments below, the above quote seems to be incorrect. Dr. Yip Swee Chooi apparently doesn’t use his body for storing the dictionary, but uses memory journeys through shops and other locations.
Gunther Karsten’s images for words:
[In the poem competition, Gunther Karsten] assigns every single word to a route point… he has created his own dictionary of images for each of the two hundred most common words that can’t easily be visualized. “And” is a circle (“and” rhymes with rund, which means round in German). “The” is someone walking on his knees (die, a German word for “the,” rhymes with Knie, the German word for “knee”). When the poem reaches a period, he hammers a nail into that locus.
How actors chunk and memorize lines:
Many actors will tell you that they break their lines into units they call “beats,” each of which involves some specific intention or goal on the character’s part, which they train themselves to empathize with. This technique, known as Method acting, was pioneered in Russia by Konstantin Stanislavski around the turn of the last century.
…[he] has been developing a new mnemonic system for the [names and faces] event that would assign numerical codes to eye color, skin color, hair color, hair length, and mouth shape.
[Anders Ericsson] told me to find a metronome and to try to memorize a card every time it clicked. Once I figured out my limits, he instructed me to set the metronome 10 to 20% faster than that and keep trying at the quicker pace until I stopped making mistakes. Whenever I came across a card that was particularly troublesome, I was supposed to make a note of it and see if I could figure out why it was giving me problems. It worked, and within a couple of days I was off the OK plateau and my card times began falling again at a steady clip.
On placing mnemonic images:
“Don’t try to see the whole image,” [Ed Cooke] said. “You don’t need to. Just focus on one salient element of whatever it is you’re trying to visualize. If it’s your girlfriend, make sure that before all else, you see her smile practice studying the whiteness of her teeth, the way her lips freeze the other details will make her more memorable, but the smile will be key. Sometimes a stab of blue that smells of oysters might be all the recall you get from some particular image, but if you know your system well, you should be able to translate that back again. Often, when you’re really coming for it, the only traces left by a speedily pack of cards will be a series of emotions with no visual content whatsoever.
Ed Cooke’s caution about changing mnemonic images:
…since every change to your mnemonic system leaves behind a trace that can come back to haunt you in competition. And if there’s one thing a mental athlete wants desperately to avoid, it’s for a single card or number to trigger multiple images on game day.
Cooke’s advice on getting to know your mnemonic images:
“Well, you’ve got to get to know your images better… Starting tonight, take a suit at a time and really spend meditative time with each character. Ask yourself what they look, feel, smell, taste, and sound like; how they walk; the cut of their clothes; their social attitude; their sexual preferences; their propensity to gratuitous violence…”
Cooke’s advice on the psychological effect of certain mnemonic images:
“I eventually had to excise my mother from my deck. I recommend you do the same.”
- How Foer trained for the “Tea Party” event: page 238
- Why to stop practicing one week before the competition: pages 238-239
- Ed Cooke on lighting the journey correctly: page 243
- Word memorization tactics: page 252
- Card recall tactics: page 256
One of the most important chapters in the book is about the history of memory techniques in education. Foer writes about why there was a backlash against memorization in education, and how things may have swung too far in the wrong direction.
Memorization has been completely ripped out of some educational methods with detrimental results. Modern experiential education is great, but it should be balanced with intense training in the memorization of information.
I remember a history teacher once telling me that it wasn’t important to memorize dates, but just to know the overall concept of events throughout history. With what I know about memory now, that was the worst possible advice. The first thing that one should do is memorize all the dates.
As the book mentions, the purpose of memory techniques isn’t rote memorization for its own sake; it is to “create a conceptual framework in which to embed” what is learned:
…you can’t have understanding without facts. And crucially, the more you know, the easier it is to know more. Memory is like a spider web that catches new information. The more it catches, the bigger it grows. And the bigger it grows, more it catches… There is a feedback loop between [memory and intelligence].
Foer writes about the link between memory and creativity, quoting Tony Buzan:
“The Art and science of memory is about developing the capacity to quickly create images that link disparate ideas. Creativity is the ability to form similar connections between disparate images and to create something new and hurl it into the future so it becomes a poem, or a building, or a dance, or a novel.”
I think that memory techniques are a very powerful way to increase creativity. Improved creativity is one of the first benefits I noticed when I first started memory training.
If you have any interest in the subject of memory, this book is essential reading. Finally, there is a book that I can recommend to people when they gave me strange looks about my hobby of trying to memorize long strings of what appear to be cold, meaningless numbers.
I see the arrival of this successful book as being a major step in paving the way for the revival of the ancient, lost craft of memory. The book is easy to read and provides a more gentle introduction to the topic than most memory enthusiasts are able to provide.
The book doesn’t provide detailed instructions on how to memorize things, so if you are interested in learning memory techniques after finishing the book, join our free community and check out my list of recommended memory books.
Read more reviews about Moonwalking with Einstein from the TLC Book Tour here:
EDIT: for another review of Moonwalking with Einstein, check out pwgearguy’s review.
If you want to learn the techniques from the book, see our how to learn memory techniques page.
Joshua Foer, author of Moonwalking With Einstein, on tour March 2011 | TLC Book Tours 19 Sep 2021
[...] Tuesday, March 15th: Mnemotechnics.org [...]
Heather J. @ TLC Book Tours 19 Sep 2021
Thank you so much for being on this book tour. I have to admit that the field of memory competition is completely new to me, so I really found your review fascinating, coming as it does from an "insider's" perspective.
Yan 19 Sep 2021
I agree that Foer's book is a fascinating read but there are some details he got wrong.
Like, for instance, Dr. Yip Swee Chooi doesn't use his body parts but a journey for each page on the book, with each word on the page placed on a locus on the journey.
You can find the interview done by Ed Cooke in this video:
Josh 19 Sep 2021
Thanks -- I updated the post above.
JeanJean 19 Sep 2021
Hey, I'm learning English, and one of the best way to learn is to read, books and articles that's matters to us, I'm very interrested about memory and your book is rather exiting as I read your resumer, so I go to amazon.fr now and I buy your book, promise !
JeanJean 19 Sep 2021
That's Ok, just bought from amazon.fr, I'm waiting for the book now, plan to receive in 5-6 days.
Moonwalking with Einstein – Book Review - Mind Your Decisions 19 Sep 2021
[...] Tuesday, March 15th: Mnemotechnics.org [...]
Review: Moonwalking with Einstein by Joshua Foer « Amy Reads 19 Sep 2021
[...] March 7th: Man of La Book Wednesday, March 9th: Sophisticated Dorkiness Tuesday, March 15th: Mnemotechnics.org Thursday, March 17th: Mind Your Decisions Monday, March 28th: Amy Reads Wednesday, March 30th: In [...]
How to Evolve in Your Lifetime | Empress of the Global Universe 19 Sep 2021
[...] compared with people who maintain more neurotic and self-focused personality traits. And as Joshua Foer has described in his recent book, “Moonwalking with Einstein,” anyone can learn 2,500-year-old [...]
Here's How You Can Evolve Within Your Lifetime | Progressive Impact -- Douglas LaBier 19 Sep 2021
[...] and self-focused personality traits. And, as Joshua Foer has described in his recent book, Moonwalking with Einstein, anyone can learn 2500 year-old techniques for dramatically improving your memory; feats that can [...]
Zoomy 19 Sep 2021
"…[he] has been developing a new mnemonic system for the [names and faces] event that would assign numerical codes to eye color, skin color, hair color, hair length, and mouth shape."
I missed that part when I was reading the book myself. That's not me - I might have mentioned it as the kind of thing people might do, but I don't do it myself :-)
Josh 19 Sep 2021
Thanks -- I've updated the post above with a link to your comment.
I like the idea though. :)
By the way, there's a Wiki page that tries to compile information about all the known techniques for names and faces here. Anyone can edit the page...
Goodreads Choice Awards — Mnemotechnics.org 19 Sep 2021
[...] Foer’s Moonwalking with Einstein is a nominee for Goodread.com’s Best Nonfiction category. I think it would be great if a book [...]
Finishing My Ben System Images — Mnemotechnics.org 19 Sep 2021
[...] If I have trouble with the faces, I will add the facial characteristics of real people to some of the mythological beings. I prefer to do it that way than to use people I know I in my system–for the same reason Ed Cooke had to excise his mother from the deck. [...]
tourshi 19 Sep 2021
Thanks for the post, quick question from a newbie such as myself--does memorizing random numerical sequences/strings amount to any practical memory gains in day to day life?
What I mean by this, is do seemingly meaningless memory exercises result in meaningful results in day to day memory?
What is your experience with that?
Carl 19 Sep 2021
@ tourshi I've read the book. And I believe the conclusion was an answer to your question. And the answer is generally, no.
General memory improvement is elusive.
Improvement on particular categories you may need can be achieved with practice with those specific things.
I'm just as new, but based on what I've read I think I want to put in the practice and prep work necessary to remember: Names and Faces better, to memorize a deck of cards, for playful reasons, and I need to work on memorizing formula's and lists of vocabulary.
Like I said. My understanding from Moonwalking With Einstein and other blog posts is that all improvements are the result of techniques learned, and techniques are often subject specific. And really most natural applications are either unnatural or unnecesary in real life. Memorizing numbers for instance, the only numbers we need to memorize in 'real life' are ID numbers and phone numbers. There aren't as many ID numbers as we complain about, and who remembers phone numbers when we can justg input them into our phones virtually errror free.
Carl 19 Sep 2021
Actually if one of you more experienced fellows wishes to reply to tourshi aswell I would greatly appreciate any tips in memorizing formulea.
I've tried making visual images and the like. sqare bee's for b squared, and squared off roots for square roots. But I don't know if it is helping.
Bill Gates’ Review of Moonwalking with Einstein — Mnemotechnics.org 19 Sep 2021
[...] on September 14, 2012 I just saw a couple of blog posts by Bill Gates where he highly recommends Moonwalking with Einstein. Check out this great mention: Of the five books I finished over vacation, the one that impressed [...]
An Introduction to Mnemonic Number Systems — Mnemotechnics.org 19 Sep 2021
[...] Person-Action-Object (PAO) System — made famous in Moonwalking with Einstein [...]
anibalenglish 19 Sep 2021
Dominic O' Brien advocates that seemingly meaningless memory exercises can lead somebody to a general better memory. In order to be able to perform memory feats, you're going to need to develop concentration - the bigger your concentration span gets, the better you'll get to memorize anything.
Check this out "Dominic now refers to his dyslexic condition in the past tense as though he no longer has it. It is quite obvious that his attention problems have disappeared (you don't get to be World Memory Champion with failing concentration!) - but what about his dyslexia? Dominic is totally convinced that having trained his memory to a remarkable level (he would be the first to agree with me that "remarkable" refers to the fact that very few people do, rather than that they can't), his mind has evolved to the degree that dyslexia no longer causes him any problems".
tourshi 19 Sep 2021
That's really interesting, thanks for sharing :)
An Update for the San Francisco Bay Memory Club — Mnemotechnics.org 19 Sep 2021
[...] Moonwalking with Einstein by Joshua Foer — this book provides a background about the subculture of “mental athletes” which you are now a part of! [...]